Allie Reynolds
October 11, 1946: A trade is made in baseball, and it is a rarity: One that works out very well for both teams.
The New York Yankees trade 2nd baseman Joe Gordon to the Cleveland Indians for pitcher Allie Reynolds. Gordon, the 1942 American League Most Valuable Player, was nicknamed "Flash," not because of his flashy defense, but because he reminded people of science-fiction film hero Flash Gordon, played by Buster Crabbe, who also played another sci-fi hero, Buck Rogers.
Joe Gordon secured his (posthumously-elected) Hall of Fame status by helping the Indians win the 1948 World Series, on October 11, 2 years to the day after the trade. This was his 5th title, having won 4 with the Yankees. But the Yankees had gotten George "Snuffy" Stirnweiss in a separate trade, and then had Jerry Coleman, Billy Martin and Bobby Richardson at the keystone sack for the next 15 years.
Joe Gordon
The Indians needed a veteran infield presence like Gordon, and their owner, Bill Veeck, was willing to trade any pitcher except the future Hall-of-Famer Bob Feller. Yankee general manager Larry MacPhail asked his best player, Joe DiMaggio, which one he should take. The Yankee Clipper said, "Take Reynolds. I'm a fastball hitter, but he can buzz his hard one by me any time he has a mind to." In other words, "He's really good, so even if he does nothing for us, at least he won't be doing anything to us."
That fastball, and his Cherokee heritage, got Reynolds a nickname that applied to Native Americans and a famous train of the time: The "Superchief." Still, he was only 51-47, with a 3.31 ERA, for his career when the Yankees acquired him. There was no indication that he would become a great pitcher.
But he did. In a rotation that already included Vic Raschi, the "Springfield Rifle," the Yankees won the 1947 World Series. In 1948, the Yankees obtained Eddie Lopat, a lefthander specializing in off-speed pitches, known as "the Junkman."
And with new manager Charles "Casey" Stengel coming in for the 1949 season, and pitching the speedy righthander Reynolds followed by the junkballing lefty Lopat, followed by the speeding righthander Raschi, the Yankees had a very tough combination that won the next 5 World Series: 1949, '50, '51, '52 and '53 -- each time with a different 4th starter. So this trade helped the Yankees get 6 titles.
Reynolds only won 20 games once, in 1952, but that was partly because Stengel also frequently used him as a reliever. Had he come along 30 years later, he might have been a big blazing righthanded closer in the mold of Goose Gossage, Rob Dibble or Rod Beck. He hurt his back in 1954, but still managed to go 13-4 at age 37. He then retired: Having invested in oil wells in Oklahoma, he could afford to play for the love of the game, and then walk away.
The Yankees honored him with a Plaque for Monument Park in Yankee Stadium in 1989, although they have never retired his Number 22. He died in 1994.
*
October 11, 1946 was a Friday. There was baseball action on this day, Game 5 of the World Series at Fenway Park in Boston. The Boston Red Sox beat the St. Louis Cardinals, 6-3. Ted Williams singled in a run in the bottom of the 1st inning, and Cardinal manager Eddie Dyer panicked, taking out starter Howie Pollet. While Al Brazle got out of the jam, he gave up a home run to Leon Culberson in the 6th inning, and fell apart in the 7th. In contrast, Joe Dobson went the distance for the Sox, holding Stan Musial to a 1-for-3 day.
The Sox thus took a 3-games-to-2 lead in the Series. All they had to do was win 1 of 2 games at Sportsman's Park in St. Louis. They just had to win 1 more World Series game, and they would have their 1st World Championship since 1918. It took them another 58 years to get that title.
There was also a game played in the All-America Football Conference: The football version of the Brooklyn Dodgers and the Chicago Rockets played to a tie, 21-21 at Ebbets Field.
And there were 7 college football games:
* Number 8 Georgia beat Number 19 Kentucky, 28-13 at Sanford Stadium in Athens, Georgia.
* Georgetown beat Fordham, 8-7 at Griffith Stadium in Washington. Georgetown dropped their football program after the 1950 season, re-established it at NCAA Division III in 1973, and moved up to Division I-AA/Football Championship Subdivision in 1993. Fordham dropped their program after 1954, restored it to Division III in 1973, and to I-AA/FCS in 1989.
* South Carolina beat Furman University, 14-7 at Furman's Sirrine Stadium in Greenville, South Carolina.
* George Washington University beat Rollins College, 13-0 at Orlando Stadium (now Camping World Stadium). Orlando-based Rollins dropped their football program after the 1949 season, and D.C.-based GWU dropped theirs after 1946.
* The University of Miami beat Texas Christian University, 20-12 at Burdine Stadium (later renamed the Orange Bowl) in Miami.
* Wichita State University beat Drake University, 12-6 at Drake Stadium in Des Moines, Iowa. Drake downgraded their program to Division I-AA/FCS in 1971, and Wichita State dropped theirs after 1985.
* And Southern Methodist University beat Oklahoma A&M, 15-6 at the Cotton Bowl in Dallas. A&M became Oklahoma State in 1958.
